logo
Mendik Matters

    Remembering Seven Dirty Words

    Can you name all seven dirty words?  Justice Stevens can, and did — in FCC v. Pacifica Foundation, 438 U.S. 726 (1978), decided 33 years ago on July 3.

    In December, 1973, the Federal Communications Commission received a letter from John Douglas, a member of Morality in Media.  He and his fifteen-year-old son had heard a weekday afternoon radio broadcast of George Carlin’s “seven dirty words” routine.  It had been aired by WBAI, part of the Pacifica Foundation public radio network. The FCC subsequently issued a declaratory order holding the broadcast indecent.  No fine was imposed but the order was placed in the station’s license file.  All parties viewed the issue as an exciting test case and Pacifica appealed to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, which reversed.

    The Supreme Court then reversed the Court of Appeals in a 5-4 decision.  The majority opinion, authored by Justice Stevens, concluded that the FCC’s order did not violate the First Amendment.  The court held that in the context of broadcasting, the interests of child welfare and possibly unwilling audiences justify regulatory efforts to limit indecent content to certain time slots.  The opinion was cited frequently in the Supreme Court’s recent “fleeting expletives” case involving Fox Television Stations.

    Further resources:

    Nadine Strossen, Constitutional Law and Values – Version ’08 (Not Necessarily an Upgrade), 53 N.Y.L.S. L. Rev. 735 (2008-2009).

    George Carlin, Last Words (2009).

    Exploring Constitutional Conflicts: Regulation of Indecent Speech, http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/indecentspeech.htm (last visited June 25, 2011).

    Richard A. Parker, Free Speech on Trial: Communication Perspectives on Landmark Supreme Court Decisions (2003).

    Adam M. Samaha, The Story of FCC v. Pacifica Foundation (and Its Second Life) (Public Law and Legal Theory Working Paper No. 314).


    Search

    Subscribe

    Via E-mail:

    Library Links

  • Contact Us
  • Library Home Page
  • Search the Library's Online Catalog
  • Facebook  Find Us on Facebook
  • Recent Posts

    • Mendik Library hours from Monday March 20, 2023 to Friday May 19, 2023
    • Bloomberg Law training sessions postponed
    • The Right to Counsel
    • Happy Women’s History Month!
    • Get back into research after spring break: Bloomberg Law (BLAW) training sessions on Mon., 3/20 and Thurs., 3/23
    • The Law School Survey of Student Engagement
    • Mendik Library Hours from 2/23/2023 to 3/19/2023
    • Congratulations to our Valentine’s Day Info Hunt Winners!!
    • The Mendik Library will be open on Monday February 20, 2023.
    • Love is In the Air at the Mendik Library!

    Categories

  • Bar
  • Blogs
  • CALI
  • Courts
  • Courts, International
  • Current Affairs
  • Electronic Legal Research
  • Events
  • Exams
  • Food and Drink
  • Law
  • Law Practice
  • Law School
  • Legal History
  • Legal News
  • Library Information
  • Mobile App
  • New Acquisitions
  • News
  • One Ls
  • Research
  • Schedule
  • tax
  • Uncategorized
  • Web
  • Web/Tech
  • Welcome
  • Archives

    © 1997-2023 New York Law School | 185 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013 | 212.431.2100 | Policies